Created + Printed Just For You!

Every printed piece receives our personal touch. From the creative designer, to the proofreader, to our printing team, our process ensures a flawless outcome. We have no website generated PDFs or automation. It may be a little extra work, but you're worth it.

  • Made With Love

    All of our work is done with you in mind. We are always working on adding products and ideas to offer!

  • Local, Small Business

    Located in Avon, New York we are a small business with just about fifty employees all working with one common goal: to please our customers.

  • Customer Service

    Tell us about your project! Email us or call us at 585.226.8111. You always speak to a person and work directly with your project manager when you work with us.

1 3

'Tis the Season

CHRISTMAS & HOLIDAY CARDS // VIEW ALL

1 25

For the New Addition

Birth Announcements // View All

1 18

Oh, What Fun!

All Occasion Event Invitations // View All

1 18

Share the Love

Save the Date Cards // View All

1 18

Celebrate Your Big Day

Wedding Invitations // View All

1 18

Start Something Great

Business cards // View All

1 18

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does printing take?

We generally say 3-5 days for printing, often time’s it is on the shorter end of that but we have no guarantees. Shipping is not included in the print turn around time.

How can I see my design before printing?

Absolutely! You can request a proof in the ‘Notes’ section or by checking the box to indicate that you’d like one. You’re welcome to email us at shop@printingbypennylane.com with your proof request. After sending it over, we’ll allow up to 2 business days for approval. If we don’t hear back from you, we’ll assume everything looks good and proceed with printing. Make sure to check your spam folder, just in case.

What are the shipping options & timelines?

For regular shipping, it is 2-4 day USPS shipping, expedited shipping is 1-2 day USPS shipping depending on what is available. With sample shipping, allow up to 5-7 days. Please note that sample shipping does not include a tracking number. 

We also offer local pickup at your convenience; once your order is ready you will receive an email notification and your order will be in our foyer at 1471 Rt. 15, Avon, NY 14414 available for you to stop by and pickup.

I'm looking for something not on PrintingByPennyLane.com

Great! We are a full service creative and printing team ready for whatever project and idea you have. Reach out to our Print Manager, Gina Doran at ginad@pennylaneprinting.com to get started!